IDNDR-ESCAP Regional Meeting for Asia:
Risk Reduction & Society in the 21st Century
Bangkok, 23-26 February 1999
Water Hazards, Resources and Management for Disaster Prevention:
A Review of the Asian Conditions
IDNDR 1991-1999
4. DISASTER PREVENTION AND PREPAREDNESS OPTIONS
FOR THE ESCAP REGION
4.1 Prevention and
Preparedness Approaches
4.2 Disaster
Prevention
4.3 Disaster
Preparedness
4.4 Structural
Measures for Disaster Management
4.4.1
Introduction
4.4.2
Cyclone Management
4.4.3
Flood Management
4.4.4
Water-induced Land Instability
4.4.5
Drought Management
4.5 Non-structural
Measures
4.
DISASTER PREVENTION AND PREPAREDNESS OPTIONS FOR THE ESCAP REGION
4.1
Prevention and Preparedness Approaches
The key to effective reduction in the loss of life
and damage to property resulting from tropical cyclones, storm surges,
floods and other forms of water-based disaster lies in the development
and adoption of improved disaster prevention and preparedness measures.
Disaster prevention may be described as the
application of measures that seek to prevent natural phenomena from
occurring or to limit the scope and intensity of their effects. It is
concerned with the formulation and implementation of long range
programmes and policies which are aimed at elimination of the occurrence
of disasters or the reduction of their adverse effects on the basis of a
careful assessment of vulnerability and risk. It must be emphasized that
major natural disaster phenomena such as tropical cyclones and
widespread floods cannot be prevented from occurring, but the
probability and extent of serious damaging effects can be minimized.
These measures may include both structural and non-structural
approaches, including legislative and regulatory measures.
Disaster preparedness may be described as the
application of measures which are designed to minimize loss of life and
property damage and to organize and facilitate timely and effective
rescue, relief and rehabilitation when disastrous disaster events do
occur. Again, the assessment of these risks must be undertaken in terms
of risk and vulnerability (see Chapter 7). Preparedness measures
may include forecasting and warning systems, community education, and
organization and management of disaster situations including the
preparation of operational plans, training of relief groups, the
stockpiling of supplies and the provision of the necessary funds. It is
must be supported by appropriate emergency legislation which comes into
force in disaster situations or similar emergencies which cannot be
avoided.
Prevention and preparedness measures are not isolated
activities since both can be undertaken together or one can be a
continuation of the other. This is because not all disasters can be
prevented, and preventative measures may fail to achieve their
objectives. Thus, to limit or mitigate the effects of disasters which
cannot be prevented, certain measures have to be undertaken to return
the community to normality as soon as possible after the event.
A variety of prevention and preparedness
measures has been applied in the countries of the ESCAP Region, albeit
with varying degrees of success and often in an uncoordinated fashion.
Details of these approaches are presented in Chapter 6.
As previously stated, disaster prevention and
preparedness consist of a wide range of measures, some long term and
others short-term, aimed at saving lives and minimizing the amount of
damage that might otherwise be caused. Prevention covers the long-term
aspects and is concerned with policies and programmes to prevent or
eliminate the occurrence of disasters. Preparedness covers the
short-term measures which are designed to cover the action necessary
during the approach of a possible disaster, during the existence of a
disaster situation and in the ensuing period devoted to relief and
rehabilitation. Disaster prevention and preparedness is usually
accomplished using two fundamental approaches. Firstly, it may be
achieved using permanent controls, structural or non-structural,
designed and developed in advance of the disaster. Secondly, it may be
achieved by using temporary measures, planned in advance but only put
into effect during the emergency.
4.2
Disaster Prevention
The destructive power of tropical cyclones is
manifested by strong winds, flooding and storm surges. Any disaster
prevention and preparedness system must include warnings and protective
measures against each of these effects. Winds are a fundamental property
of tropical cyclones, whilst flooding and storm surges may be a
consequence of tropical cyclones but also of other natural events.
The principal preventive measures employed to
mitigate the destructive and injurious effects of tropical cyclones
involve the introduction of building design and construction standards
aimed at improved resistance to the damaging effects of wind and water.
Disaster prevention measures attempt to lessen the
impact of flooding or storm surge on the social and economic conditions
of human settlements in floodplains or low lying coastal areas. The
range of preventative controls adopted to protect development on
floodplains includes both structural measures such as channel
modifications, flood detention storages and levees which arc designed to
reduce the incidence or extent of flooding, and non-structural measures
such as flood insurance, flood zoning restrictions, land-use management,
economic incentives, public information and community education.
Non-structural measures are intended to modify flood susceptibility and
flood impact. The range of measures available to protect against the
effects of flooding is much wider than that available to reduce the
impact of tropical cyclones.
Preventative measures to protect low-lying coastal
areas against damage from tidal inundation also include structural and
non-structural measures. The principal structural measure involve the
construction of embankments capable of withstanding the anticipated
storm surge heights and forces. Non-structural measures employ land-use
zoning and controls over occupation in high hazard areas. Building
controls are also imposed to restrict building on vulnerable areas.
These controls require that flood heights are set a safe elevation above
a given datum.
The selection of the best mix of measures to prevent
the occurrence of future flood or storm surge disasters will be based on
the consideration of all the available structural and non-structural
options. The optimal mix of measures will be based on risk analysis and
the economic performance of the overall scheme. Consideration of social
and environmental factors in addition to the legislative and legal
constrictions should be included in the planning process.
4.3
Disaster Preparedness
Disaster preparedness is seen as that action taken
when the occurrence of a tropical cyclone. flood or storm surge
threatens to become a disaster. Preparedness activities are designed to
reduce social disruption and losses to existing property and are an
essential component of overall disaster planning. They can serve in the
absence of more permanent measures to reduce the threat to loss of life
and property.
The main types of disaster preparedness include:
- forecasting and warning systems;
- evacuation from affected areas;
- flood fighting;
- flood relief;
- cyclone shelters.
Depending on the size of the drainage basin, the
length of river and the time of concentration of floodwater in the main
channel, flood forecasts and warnings may be issued well in
advance of the arrival of the flood crest on large rivers. Flash floods
originating on small catchments present special problems and usually
require some form of forecasting based on rainfall
estimates.
Although the forecasts for cyclones and floods may be
accurate and timely they may have little or no effects on the intended
recipients if the warning system for dissemination of the forecast is
inadequate. Each agency responsible for emergency operations should
receive prompt forecasts and warnings of the changing circumstances so
that action needed to meet the emergency can be achieved. Dissemination
of forecasts requires an effective communications system based on radio
broadcasts, television, newspapers, telephone and special warning
systems.
The evacuation of people from a potential or actual
disaster area is one of the most important elements of disaster
mitigation. Careful planning is necessary for the efficient evacuation
and relief of flood victims. To be effective the plan should define
hazardous areas and potential dangers. However, the difficulty in
evacuating victims and property can be increased if escape routes cannot
cope with the traffic volume, if evacuation services cannot be contacted
or suitable evacuation equipment such as trucks, boats and helicopters
are not available.
Flood fighting can be defined as the taking of
precautionary measures against disaster at times of flood or
storm-surge. These measures should aim to prevent damage or to minimize
its extent to protect life and property and in general, to ensure the
safety of the population. Successful flood fighting depends upon good
organization, thorough advance planning, well-trained personnel and the
effective coordination of operations at local, provincial and national
levels. The planning should cover all those who will be involved, from
the flood-fighting corps, municipality, town or village officers, and
the general public, to the regional and central government. It involves
the construction of temporary controls to exclude floodwater from
protected areas or the strengthening of existing structures to ensure
protection.
The main aim of relief is to provide immediate
assistance to overcome personal hardship and distress, including
essential repairs to houses and the repair and replacement of essential
items of furniture and personal effects. Relief should include the
reception and care of evacuated victims, the provision of medical
services and similar activities.
4.4
Structural Measures for Disaster Management
4.4.1
Introduction
As explained in the preceding sections of this
Chapter, a variety of both structural and non-structural measures is
available for coping with water-based disasters. These measures are
discussed in further detail below. As we have already indicated, most or
all of these methods have been used in the countries of the ESCAP Region
as part of their disaster mitigation programs. The extent to which
individual countries have applied them, and the degree to which they
have been successful, has been varied, as will be described in Chapter 6
and commented upon in Chapter 7.
4.4.2
Cyclone Management
Winds are a fundamental property of tropical
cyclones, whilst flooding and storm surges may be a consequence of
tropical cyclones but also of other natural events. A variety of
structural measures has be taken to protect lives and property against
these effects.
Tropical cyclones may produce wind velocities of 200
km per hour or more. Under these conditions, buildings are subject to
air pressure variations which can produce strong outwards forces on
roofs, ceilings and walls, leading to explosive lifting, bursting or
collapse. High winds may also induce falling debris and airborne
wreckage to be carried from adjacent buildings, and these can impact
with such force as to penetrate or severely damage conventional wall and
roof materials.
Structural precautions which have been or could be
taken to minimize the damage caused by these effects include:
- siting or re-siting of buildings in locations with minimal
exposure to high-velocity winds;
- use of special cyclone-resistant building materials;
- special forms of roof and wall construction designed to
withstand extremely high wind velocities;
- construction of cyclone shelters within or adjacent to
buildings.
In selecting a location with reduced exposure to
hazardous wind velocities, it needs to be remembered that cyclones are
generally associated with intense rainfall and possibly heavy flooding.
Clearly, buildings should not be located in positions posing increased
flood hazard.
Cyclone are also often associated with storm surges,
leading to potential flooding of coastal areas. Where possible,
buildings should not be located in surge prone locations. Alternatively,
buildings may be raised above expected flood levels. This is also a
possibility for locations which are likely to be subject to
cyclone-induced flooding.
Many countries in the region have Government or
University laboratories which conduct research into the structural
effects of tropical cyclone damage and have developed structural and
building designs and special materials to suit such conditions. Many
countries have also now developed improved structural design guidelines
and standards governing building construction in cyclone-prone areas and
these should be identified, emphasized in building regulations or
by-laws and widely publicized amongst engineers, architects, builders
and the general public.
Cyclone shelters are specially strengthened and
equipped rooms or chambers constructed inside or adjacent to individual
buildings. For short-term emergency shelters, a floor space area of
about 0.5 m2 per person is
adequate. For longer duration cyclones, which might last for 12 hours or
more, a floor space of about 1m2
per occupant is desirable.
According to the building design and layout, shelters
might be constructed inside the building, in the basement, under a
garage or other concrete floor, or as an extension on one side of the
building. Shelters should have concrete walls and a strengthened roof,
with a single door which is missile-impact resistant. They require of
course to be adequately ventilated, with a system which is not reliant
on electrical supply in case of power failure. Shelters design for
longer-duration occupancy require a water supply and toilet and all
shelters should be provided with a kit of emergency equipment, including
torch and lamp, first-aid kit, portable radio, water and food
containers, portable cooking gear and spare clothing.
4.4.3
Flood Management
(i) Levees and flood walls
The principal purpose of levees and floodwalls is to
confine floodwaters to the stream channel and a selected portion of the
floodplain. These barriers protect only the land area immediately behind
them, and are effective only against flood depths up to the chosen level
for which they were designed. However, they may create a false sense of
security about the degree of protection provided. Floods exceeding the
levels for which the levees and floodwalls are designed can cause
disastrous losses of life and property.
The requirements for the design and construction of
levees and floodwalls are governed by degree of hazard to life and
property within the protected area and by site conditions. Levees are
normally constructed of earth and require significant space to
accommodate the required base width. Floodwalls are usually constructed
of concrete or steel and take up far less room. They are more suitable
for use in congested areas.
Because levees and floodwalls can fail by
overtopping, undermining, slumping and excessive seepage, the design of
these structures should attempt to reduce the possibility of failure
from these causes. Ample freeboard, which takes into account the
settlement of levees, wave action, sedimentation of the river channel
and inaccuracies in estimation of flood levels, reduces the possibility
of overtopping of levees or floodwalls. Undermining is minimized by
locating levees or floodwalls far enough away from channels to eliminate
exposure to high velocity or scour. Proper side slopes and construction
methods minimize slumping of earth levees. Excessive seepage can be
reduced by the provision of seepage protection works. Damage can also be
caused by termites and burrowing animals. Regular inspections are
necessary to locate and remedy the damage in an early stage of
development.
Levees and floodwalls complicate the drainage of land
they protect and provision must be made for the discharge of internal
drainage water unless adequate storage is available. Discharge through
levees or floodwalls can be achieved by gravity flow through pipes
equipped with gates. When prolonged flood stages prevent gravity
outflow, the internal drainage water must be stored temporarily, removed
by pumping or disposed of using a combination of these methods.
To be effective, levees require proper maintenance.
Such maintenance should include regular inspections as well as
periodical patrols during and immediately after severe floods.
Vegetation, grazing and traffic on earth levees should be controlled.
Proper attention to any defects will help ensure against levee failure.
(ii) Channel Modification
Normal natural watercourses have a river channel of
limited capacity, which may be exceeded annually, with excess floodwater
overflowing onto the floodplain. Hydraulic improvements to the
watercourse or to the floodplain, and/or flood channels constructed
within the floodplain, enable flood waters to be passed at a lower level
than would occur naturally. In urban areas, such works also permit the
optimization of land use through improved residual drainage.
The various types of channel modification include:
- straightening, deepening or widening of the channel;
- removing vegetation or debris;
- lining the channel;
- raising or enlarging bridges and culverts which restrict flow;
- removing barriers which interfere with flow;
- installing river training works.
Channel modifications are similar to levees and
floodwalls in that they can be used to protect a specific site or
region. They can also provide the community with other positive
benefits, such as improved navigation and recreation.
Channel modifications are likely to be most effective
on steeper, smaller streams with overgrown banks and narrow floodplains.
Channel modifications are unlikely to have any significant effect in
flooding situations where there are extensive areas of overbank
flooding, or where flooding effects are dominated by tide levels.
River training works are structural measures of
various kinds which are undertaken in order to provide a more effective
channel for the passage of flood flows and sediment loads. Such works
may be designed either to retard flow rates along a river bank, in order
to reduce erosive velocities and increase the deposition of sediments,
or to provide protection for the bank against erosion or scouring.
Permeable groynes and revetments, constructed of
piling, rock, concrete, fencing materials, vegetation or other
materials, are generally used for these purposes. Groynes protrude into
the channel and are designed to divert flow away from the bank, whilst
at the same time causing an accumulation of sediment along the toe of
the bank and on the downstream side of the groyne structure. Revetments,
on the other hand, are constructed along or parallel to the bank, where
they serve to reduce the velocity of flow along the bank, thus reducing
bank erosion and allowing the river bank to stabilize.
Which of these devices should be used in a given
situation depends upon characteristics of the stream channel and the
extent and nature of the existing erosion damage. Whichever kind of
device is employed, its satisfactory long-term performance will be very
much dependent upon its continuing maintenance.
Disadvantages which are related to the use of channel
modifications include the costs of proper maintenance, the destruction
of riverine habitat for fish and wildlife, and the potential for the
aggravation of channel scouring and bank erosion if the structures are
not intelligently designed, well constructed and carefully maintained.
(iii) By-pass floodways
These structures serve two functions in flood
mitigation. Firstly they create large, shallow reservoirs which store a
portion of the flood water and hence decrease the flow in the main
channel below the diversion. Secondly, they provide an additional outlet
for water from upstream, improving flow characteristics and decreasing
water levels for some distance below the diversion. Opportunities for
the construction of floodways are limited by the topography of the area
and the availability of low-value land which can be used for the
floodway.
There are two types of by-pass floodways, natural and
constructed. A natural floodway follows the course of an existing
cross-country depression and carries floodwaters that can no longer be
carried within the river channel. The land in the floodway is generally
not different from other farmland, except that it may be low-lying. Some
floodways have control banks constructed across them, or may be bordered
by levees, in order to control the spread of floodwater. Restrictions
are usually placed on land development in floodways to ensure that
future loss and damage from major floods is reduced to a minimum and to
ensure that the floodway functions as designed.
When required, controls in the form of spillways and
gates are provided at the entrance to a floodway. Spillways take the
form of a lowered and protected section of levee which is designed to
control the amount of floodwater diverted into the floodway from the
river. As spillways can be overtopped for long periods by high velocity
floodwater, they have to be specially designed to avoid failure.
Protection can be provided by rock gabions or, where appropriate, by
building the spillway with gentle backslopes which are well grassed.
If the floodway possesses comparatively steep
bed-slopes, control banks may be built perpendicular to the direction of
flow at intervals along the length of the floodway. These banks are
similar in design to the entrance spillway, and form a series of basins
which reduce the water velocity by dropping the floodwater in
progressive steps down the floodway alignment.
Diversions are works constructed to intercept flood
flows upstream of a damage-prone area and route them around the area
through an artificial channel. Diversions may either completely re-rout
a stream or collect and transport only those flows that would cause
damage.
Diversions are particularly well suited for
protecting developed areas, because they do not usually require land
acquisition or construction within the protected area. However,
opportunities for diversions are often limited by the nature of local
land formations and soil conditions. There must also be a receiving
water body or stream channel with sufficient capacity to carry the flow
bypassed through the diversion without causing flooding.
(iv) Retarding basins and flood storage areas
Flood storage and retardation involves the
deliberate, controlled flooding of designated areas in order to minimize
overall flood losses. It permits floods exceeding a specified magnitude
to spread over low-lying lands situated behind embankments in a
controlled fashion, accomplished by the operation of gated structures or
spillway sections incorporated in the embankments. The diversion of
floodwater, when carefully controlled, will reduce the flood peak at
downstream locations and confine flooding to within the flood control
system.
Areas selected for flood storage and retardation are
traditionally low-lying locations which have a history of flooding. By
the formulation of proper controls it is possible to utilize these areas
for habitation and agricultural purposes, on the understanding that they
will be flooded periodically. This calls for the preparation of a
comprehensive programme of flood operation, a knowledge of the depth and
extent of area inundated, the imposition of controls to ensure
predictable flood behaviour and the implementation of a reliable flood
forecasting and warning system to ensure timely and safe evacuation.
Special provisions are also required for the protection of emergency
services and for flood refuge areas.
To reduce the damages associated with controlled
flooding, it is necessary to provide drainage works capable of emptying
the flood storage area as quickly as possible after the cessation of
main river flooding.
Retarding basins reduce downstream flood flows in
both mainstream and urban drainage situations. They allow small flows to
pass unimpeded but trap a portion of larger flows. In urban areas,
retarding basins are most suitable for small streams which respond
quickly to rainfall and/or stormwater flooding. However, they introduce
a number of inherent problems, which should be carefully evaluated for
each particular situation. These may include the following:
- basins may require a substantial area to achieve the necessary
storage;
- long duration or multi-peak storms (when the basin is filled
from a previous peak) can increase the risk of overtopping or
breaching;
- the impact on floods larger than those for which they are
designed is limited.
Sites for retarding basins in developed urban areas
are generally limited in number and extent. Available sites are usually
restricted to established recreational areas, such as parks, playing
fields and parking lots. In new urban developments or re-developments,
the incorporation of a system of retarding basins at the planning stage
can result in effective flood protection for those areas.
Retarding basins are sometimes constructed by
building an earth embankment across the watercourse and providing outlet
facilities to control releases appropriate for the capacity of the
downstream channel. The outlet facility usually takes the form of a box
or pipe culvert. If earthworks are used for the construction of the
basin embankment, the provision of adequate spillway capacity is
essential to protect the basin from failure by overtopping if flows
exceed the design flood.
Land along the river and natural depressions on the
floodplain can be utilized for the off-river storage of floodwaters.
Flood flows are diverted into them in order to reduce flood peaks
downstream. The efficiency of operation of such storages can usually be
improved by providing them with suitable intake structures for
controlled filling and outlet structures arranged to permit controlled
releases when downstream conditions allow.
(v) Flood mitigation reservoirs
In appropriate circumstances dams can be constructed
to create reservoirs which control major flood flows by temporarily
storing flood waters and releasing them at a safe flow rate. Such
devices may be used to control floods arising from existing catchment
conditions or to offset the impact of proposed land use changes. The
amount of storage required depends upon the degree of protection needed
and the downstream channel capacity.
The degree of mitigation provided by a flood control
reservoir depends on the combination of dam storage, spillway capacity
and the pattern of flood inflows. The effect of storage is to decrease
the flood peak without reducing the total volume of floodwater. The
reduction of the flood peak is achieved at the expense of an increased
duration of dam releases at lower rates. For dams equipped with gates or
valves, the way in which these controls are operated will determine the
rate of release and the degree of downstream mitigation.
The protection afforded by a surface reservoir is
greatest in the area immediately downstream of the dam. Protection
further downstream is reduced by tributary flows and by run-off from
land adjacent to the river. Protection may also decrease over time if
the reservoir capacity is diminished by siltation. Surface reservoirs
have the greatest potential to mitigate floods when they are empty.
Flood mitigation reservoirs are mostly used on small
and moderate-sized streams. The large areas of land required to store
the flood flows of major rivers are generally no longer available,
especially where they involve the flooding of valuable agricultural
lands. Many sites that are geologically and topographically suitable may
require very considerable and expensive land acquisition and the
displacement of large populations. The cost of large reservoirs can
generally only be justified where they protect heavily developed urban
areas and are the only practical means for significantly reducing flood
damages. It is usual practice to reserve a component of the available
storage capacity in multi-purpose dams for flood mitigation purposes. In
such cases, careful coordination is necessary to permit flood mitigation
reservoirs to serve also for water supply or irrigation purposes.
A major disadvantage of flood mitigation reservoirs
is that downstream residents often do not appreciate that they can only
control floods up to the peak rate for which they were designed.
Complementary land use controls need therefore to be enforced to prevent
unsafe development and encroachment on the downstream floodplain.
(vi) Drainage evacuation systems
Drainage water produced by storm runoff from within
the protected area behind levees or floodwalls may be disposed of by
various means, which include:
- gravity release through pipes fitted with gates during periods
of low river flow;
- temporary accumulation of drainage flow in storage areas;
- pumping of interior drainage water during periods when gravity
drainage outflow is restricted by backwater.
Pumping is usually required for the disposal of
interior drainage water whenever sufficient discharge by gravity flow
cannot be achieved, which may be because of limited outlet capacity,
insufficient storage capacity or the effects of backwater caused by
flooding.
The design of drainage works for the removal of flood
waters accumulating within the low-lying areas behind levees or
floodwalls requires consideration of the entire drainage network
servicing the protected area. Coordinated use of storage areas,
channels, pipe systems and gravity outlets is needed so that the pump
capacity, size and period of operation can be optimized. The efficient
planning and design of pumping plants will involve careful selection of
the required water removal rate, the auxiliary drainage facilities
needed to minimize the pumping requirements and the location of the
pumping plant to provide an effective outlet to the entire drainage
system.
The period of pumping may be reduced by increasing
the amount of available storage. This may be achieved by excavation.
Where this is not practical, adequate pumping capacity must be installed
to safely discharge any drainage inflow volume in excess of the
available storage capacity.
4.4.4
Water-induced Land Instability
There is a variety of structural or mechanical
measures which can be applied to reduce the potential for land
instability in areas where occupation cannot be prohibited. These
measures might include the following:
- preventing or diverting runoff flows around critical sites;
- de-watering sites using drainage systems;
- planting trees or shrubs which remove sub-surface water by
transpiration;
- planting deep-rooted vegetation to bind sub-soil material;
- underpinning foundations to stable rock;
- battering slopes to stable grades;
- constructing retaining walls along the toes of critical slopes.
4.4.5
Drought Management
There is a variety of structural measures which can
be taken to mitigate the effects of severe drought. These essentially
revolve around the careful management and conservation of surface and
groundwater water resources. They can be considered in two categories -
large-scale measures and small scale or on-farm measures.
Large-scale surface-water conservation measures
revolve around the provision of large water storage reservoirs for the
regulation of natural streamflow and the delivery of this water to
critical areas, sometimes over considerable distances, through
irrigation, stock or domestic water supply systems.
The availability of suitable and economical sites for
large dams is limited and new sites need to be chosen with care.
Unfortunate experiences with very large storages in many developing
countries, particularly in tropical regions, have shown that they can
have serious adverse environmental, social and economic consequences and
they need to be planned and designed with very considerable care.
Efficient utilization of available damsites and
economic considerations suggest that where possible, large water
storages should be designed and operated as multi-purpose structures,
incorporating where possible and appropriate irrigation, flood
mitigation, power generation and recreational functions. These may not
be mutually consistent, so that multi-purpose design requires a comprise
solution based on the best overall net benefits to all potential users.
Irrigation, stock and domestic water supply delivery
and distribution systems also need care in their design and location.
Increasingly, environmental considerations may impose special restraints
where proposed channel or pipeline routes may traverse areas of natural
significance, wildlife habitat or historical or cultural value.
Unfortunate experience in many countries, where
large-scale irrigation districts have been developed on semi-arid lands
on the flood plains of major rivers, has been the development of
salinity and water-logging in irrigated soils. In some cases, this has
led to the total devastation of irrigated land and made it unsuitable
for any form of agricultural activity. Within the ESCAP Region, it has
occurred extensively in Australia, China, India, Pakistan and Thailand.
To avoid the possibility of future degradation from
this cause, new irrigation areas need to be carefully sited and selected
on the basis of the soil type, the nature of the underlying strata, the
quality of the irrigation water to be use, and the ability to provide an
adequate drainage and disposal system. The build up of salts in the
soil, and the potential for water-logging, can be substantially reduced
or eliminated through the provision of an appropriate drainage
infrastructure and this must be considered an essential component of any
irrigation system. Drainage water may be too high in salinity for safe
disposal into a major watercourse, in which case an effective disposal
process, such as transpiration from an irrigated salt-tolerant woodland
or evaporation from an evaporation basin, could provide an effective
solution.
In the ESCAP Region, groundwater is used extensively
for irrigation, domestic and stock water supply purposes. Groundwater
required careful management if it is to be available in adequate
quantity and quality on a long-term basis, and particularly through
prolonged drought conditions. There are some structural devices that can
be used to improve the availability of groundwater supplies.
On the larger scale, groundwater distribution systems
need special construction measures to control losses and optimize
delivery efficiency. Artesian bores should always be capped and provided
with adequate control valves, whilst all bores should be fitted with
flow meters. Substantial seepage and evaporation losses may be
experienced when groundwater supplies are delivered over considerable
distances through unlined earthen channel systems, and pipeline delivery
is much to be preferred. At the delivery end, temporary storage in tanks
and the installation of well-designed domestic, irrigation delivery or
stockwater troughing systems is highly desirable.
Where possible, groundwater supplies should be
managed in conjunction with surface water supplies on an integrated,
conjunctive use basis. Where appropriate, groundwater resources might be
able to be replenished using surface water, particularly when excess
water flows are available during flood periods. Detention storages
designed to hold back floodwaters for a sufficient period of time to
enable infiltration into an underlying aquifer are generally used for
this purpose. These recharge storages need to be carefully sited over
foundations which are permeable and facilitate the infiltration process,
by contrast with more normal dam construction where a site offering low
seepage losses is desirable.
On the small of farm-level scale, a variety of
solutions is also available. In arid areas with intermittent rainfall,
or on higher rainfall areas with marked seasonal rainfall patterns, the
construction of appropriately designed and sited surface reservoirs is a
common practice. These are principally constructed by excavation and/or
by building an earth embankment. If they are to be used for irrigation,
they need to be as large as possible and located on sites which provide
a maximum of storage capacity per unit of excavation required for their
construction. For stock and domestic use, particularly in arid areas,
they need to be as deep as possible, with minimal surface area, to
reduce long-term evaporation losses.
Where farm storages are filled by surface runoff,
they should be equipped with an emergency spillway of adequate capacity.
Where runoff is low and intermittent, the catchment or watershed area
needs to be as large as possible and might need to be extended by the
construction of diversion and collection devices such as catch drains.
Under extremely arid conditions, the use of sealed catchment areas, with
paved or rolled earth surfaces, might be necessary where the high cost
of doing so is not an important factor.
Where groundwater or intermittent streamflow is
available, above-ground reservoirs may be constructed and filled by
pumping. Large offstream storages, called ring tanks, filled by pumping
from a sump adjacent to a watercourse during flood flow periods, are
commonly used in inland Australia for irrigation purposes. Elsewhere,
smaller circular reservoirs called turkey's nest tanks, constructed by
pushing soil from the outside around their perimeter and filled by
windmills from an underlying aquifer, are widely used for stock water
purposes.
4.5
Non-structural Measures
The vulnerability of land and property to
water-related natural disasters can be reduced by structural works. The
potential impact of these events can be further reduced by the
imposition of land use controls, designed to manage land degradation and
minimize exposure to the risk of disasters which cannot be avoided. To
achieve this objective, legislative controls which empower the relevant
government authorities to direct land use planning policies and
practices related to watershed management need to be adopted and
implemented. Whilst most of these measures have been introduced by
individual countries within the ESCAP Region, they have not always be
adopted along with a comprehensive range of structural measures in an
integrated and coordinated fashion.
Such controls should strive to ensure that an
effective and comprehensive legal and administrative system is adopted
which addresses the problems of land degradation, environmental
protection, and disaster mitigation in an coordinated fashion and is
consistent with the principles of sustainable resource development. Such
a system requires an integrated approach to the management and
protection of natural resources, including land, water, vegetation and
human activity, undertaken on the basis of a "total watershed"
approach. This approach recognized that changes to the natural
environment in the upper watershed will influence conditions in
downstream areas, and significantly increase their potential for damage
by flooding and drought.
Legalization should establish national standards for
watershed management and downstream land occupancy which relate to the
use, development and protection of land in a way which will minimize the
risk to populations during the occurrence of water related natural
disasters, particularly when they are brought about by the degradation
of natural resources. Activities within a watershed should be controlled
and protected through a comprehensive watershed management plan which
places restrictions on those activities which can increase the risk of
damage. Under this type of legislation, consent would be required for:
- large-scale land clearing;
- rural land development and use;
- forestry, mining and extractive industries;
- rezoning of land for urban use;
- occupation of flood plain land, steep slopes and other hazardous
areas.
Where it is economically and socially acceptable, and
population pressures and the demand for additional productive land allow
it, land use zoning may provide the most effective and least costly
solution to the problems of disaster management. This requires the
prohibition or restriction of agricultural development or urban
settlement in locations which are particularly susceptible to flooding,
cyclonic damage or land instability. Where this is not feasible, land
use controls might still be employed to restrict the use of the land to
activities which are compatible with potential instability or result in
minimal damage and loss of life should disaster events occur. This might
include such means as the prohibition or restriction of clearing or
logging of watersheds or the prohibition of urban settlement from land
areas at hazard.
The various categories of non-structural controls
available for disaster management and mitigation comprise the following:
- Legislative and regulatory measures for controlling land
occupancy, structural standards and emergency policies and
services;
- and-use zoning;
- warning systems;
- emergency agencies, facilities and equipment;
- evacuation and flood relief services;
- community education.
All of these activities must be provided for in an
integrated and coordinated fashion and supported by appropriate
legislative requirements and administrative arrangements if they are to
be successful.
Of these devices, all are essential but perhaps the
most likely to contribute most to overall regional and local disaster
protection and preparedness is the technique of land use control,
effected through land zoning plans and regulations.
Carefully prepared zoning plans are the basis for
effective land use control. A variety of modern techniques, including
remote sensing, satellite imagery, global positioning equipment and
geographical information systems (GIS) provide effective tools for the
preparation of basic topographical and geographical information.
Geographical information systems utilize geographical
data and information with respect to three components: spatial data,
which pertain to the locational aspects of geographical features, along
with their spatial dimensions; attribute data, which pertain to the
description, measurement and classification of geographical features;
and time, which is particularly important in natural hazard assessment
because of the rapidity with which geographical features may alter
during the occurrence of disaster events.
The collection of such data has been greatly
facilitated by the availability of various kinds of remote sensing
systems. Its incorporation into a computer-compatible format, and its
ability to be manipulated within the computer for rapid data analysis,
classification and presentation, has been further facilitated by the
ready availability of digital mapping devices and software programmes,
which allow the ready transformation of analogue data from maps or
remote sensing images into computer-usable format.
A GIS has four functional components, which comprise:
- a data input subsystem, which collects and processes spatial
data from sources such as existing maps and remote-sensing
imagery;
- a data storage and retrieval sub-system, which organizes data in
a structured form and allows it to be retrieved in various forms
for subsequent manipulation, analysis or display;
- a data manipulation and analysis sub-system allowing the
modification or reorganization of data according to given rules
and providing a basis for the preparation and manipulation of
models of the geographic area; and
- a data-reporting sub-system capable of displaying all or
selected parts of the data base in chosen tabular or cartographic
formats.
A key advantage of the GIS approach is that it
permits the integration of a wide range of categories of data and the
merging or overlaying of various groupings of data, which greatly
facilitates the use of the data for design, planning or
policy-implementation purposes. By way of example, plans of urban and
industrial development can be superimposed on topographic maps and plans
of communication systems and the whole overlain by maps of major flood
level contours to provide a basis for floodplain zoning rules. A further
key advantage is that the GIS system permits the aggregation of spatial
and attribute data into models of the land or resource system under
study and provides a basis for the simulated operation of such models
according to a variety of scenarios as a basis for planning and design
problem-solving. In integrated catchment management, as well as disaster
management, the model-forming capabilities of GIS packages are of very
substantial potential value for management purposes, particularly as a
basis for optimizing models, decision support systems and expert
systems.
There is also a number of non-structural techniques
available for drought mitigation. These include a variety of farming and
stock management measures, as well as a variety of government policy,
legislative, administrative and fiscal measures.
At the farm level, effective drought management
procedures may include the following:
- conservation farming practices designed to improve the
infiltration and retention of soil moisture;
- pasture improvement;
- the application of fodder conservation techniques;
- the management of stocking rates to avoid overgrazing and fodder
shortage;
- the introduction of more drought-resistant plant and livestock
varieties.
At the government level, effect drought management
practices may include the following;
- the provision of drought-relief funding;
- the use of taxation relief and other fiscal measures including
long-term, low-interest rate loans to encourage conservation
farming, good stock management practices and water conservation;
- the organization and coordination of government agencies for the
provision of drought relief and assistance in drought management;
- the development and implementation of advisory and extension
services to educate and assist the farming community;
- the development, in association with other nations when
appropriate, for research into the factors causing drought
conditions, the forecasting of drought events and the operation of
drought warning systems.
Where relevant, these measures need to be backed by
appropriate legislation, policy promulgation and agency response.
Last Section Back
to top Next Section
|